Miceál O’Hurley is currently one of the leading experts on the instrumentalization of religion.
He is an Irish-American expert, political scientist, journalist, defense and security analyst, and specialist in international conflict resolution. He serves as editor-in-chief and diplomatic correspondent for Diplomacy in Ireland – European Diplomat and has extensive experience as a war correspondent in international conflict zones, including Ukraine.
In an exclusive interview with Libertas Fidei, we discuss how such a blatant instrumentalization of religion became possible, how the Moscow Patriarchate became a tool of the Kremlin, whether the Western world recognizes the threats it faces, and what the future holds for our shared Christian home.
Today, we publish the first part of our conversation.
Mr. O’Hurley, оver the past decade, we have witnessed a series of dramatic revelations and disturbing discoveries concerning the activities of the Moscow Patriarchate. Several European countries have seen espionage scandals involving members of the Russian Orthodox clergy. In Ukraine, law enforcement authorities are investigating numerous cases of alleged collaboration between clergy members and Russian intelligence services and occupation authorities.
In your view, has the Western world — Europe, the United Kingdom, and the United States — come to recognise that the Russian Orthodox Church may function not only as a religious institution but also as an instrument of the Kremlin’s foreign policy and intelligence services? Have Western governments fully grasped the scale of this threat?
The West’s tardiness in recognising the deformations in the Moscow Patriarchate is regrettable, but understandable. Russian Orthodoxy was rendered incredibly complex because of its domestic history and few have studied its political evolution.
Historically, the West tended to ignore Orthodoxy. Catholics and Protestants wrote the East out of history. Even Gibbons chose to call Constantinople “Byzantium” as a way of distancing Western minds from the reality that Orthodoxy and Eastern European history survived, and even thrived, outside of Western attention. It is only relatively recently that the confluence of Russian Orthodoxy with Moscow’s geopolitical ambitions necessitated the West awakening to a hybrid animal – a Church that uses worship and catechism to mask its behaviour as a State security service organ promoting a Russkiy Mir (Russian World).
The very foundations of the Moscow Patriarchate began with scandal. Ecumenical Patriarch Jeremias was lured to Moscow with the promise of alms to aid the Church following the fall of Constantinople to the Ottoman Turks. Boris Godunov then held him prisoner under cruel conditions until he agreed to recognise Moscow as a Patriarchate. To further bind the Russian Orthodox Church to the State, Tsar Peter abolished the Moscow Patriarchate in 1721 and rendered clergy civil servants. Except for a very brief period during the Russian Revolution when the Moscow Patriarchate was restored in the vacuum of State stability, the Soviets again abolished it until appointing Sergius as Moscow Patriarch provided he and the Russian Orthodox Church be obedient to the Supreme Soviet. That twisted symphonia, born of violence and deceit and is maintained under Putin and Patriarch Kirill.
Your publications on the Moscow Patriarchate are distinguished by their courage and forthright assessments. At the same time, you have been honoured by Constantinople as a man deeply rooted in his faith and the Orthodox tradition. What motivates your research and publications―truth or faith?
We are called to live in this world in a condition marred by sin, the adulation of power and yet one infused with the gift of faith and the Church Christ left us. We experience the world as we have made it―not as God created it. Equally so, we are called to make the world better.
Our agency as a human person compels us to journey towards Christ in what we call Theosis―sharing in God’s grace and divine nature. Consequently, when confronted by evil we are left with no moral alternative or ethical choice but to name it and confront it. Hence, the research and publication about the Russian Orthodox Church’s decent into being part of Russia’s intelligence apparatus.
The decision by the Moscow Patriarchate to engineer a non-Orthodox theology of sanctification by violence―their “Holy War” doctrine―is not rooted in either Christ or the Gospel but in both Russian State policy and apologetics. Acclaiming Russian soldiers who die fighting in Ukraine to be martyrs is obscene. We must condemn the sanctification of violence and deformation of Orthodoxy.
With brute force, Russia, aided by the Moscow Patriarchate’s un-Orthodox confession of faith, are attempting to redefine the world. The sorority of nations made great human progress in embracing governance by the rule of law and until Russia invaded Moldova, Georgia, and Ukraine, it maintained peace in Europe after centuries of internecine warfare. The Moscow Patriarchate’s promotion of a Russkiy Mir which embraces the proverbial “law of the jungle” where might makes right seeks to upend world order and disrupt peace.
What the Moscow Patriarchate is preaching and teaching is the destruction of the Orthodox Christian message of love, peace, cooperation, mercy, and goodness as we know it and in doing so disfiguring the very image of Christ is indelibly imprinted on our souls at Baptism. Their perverse Holy War theology celebrates violence, rape, summary executions, and wanton warfare. The Moscow Patriarchate and their friends in the Kremlin believe warfare, invasion and occupation to be an acceptable modality by which they hope to recondition the world into believing egregious warfare to is an acceptable exercise of government policy provided it is waged in the name of Christ.
Consider the chilling words of Putin’s close advisor, an intimate friend to Moscow Patriarch Kirill, Russian Orthodox philosopher Alexander Dugin: “We love you, we respect you. And even if we are forced to kill you, we do so by shooting in the heart, in the face, in the head our own brothers and sisters. It is very difficult… We do this in the name of salvation, in the name of transformation”.
This kind of ideology is remarkably similar to how national socialism justified horrendous evil in the name of what they saw as goodness.
But no, my research, publications and interviews are not courageous, though I thank you for the compliment. They are simply the product of faith speaking truth to power. As for anything that might interfere with my research and publication? I have offered to renounce any honour that might interfere with my exercise of conscience, intellectual inquiry, research, and the freedom to publish. What I say and write are my personal views, not those of my Church, any Patriarchate or institution.
What was your personal and intellectual journey towards understanding the role of the Moscow Patriarchate in contemporary Russian politics? Was there a particular moment, event or revelation that fundamentally changed your perception of the Russian Orthodox Church?
I used to attend Russian Orthodox liturgies in a small chapel in Lower Manhattan where a “White Russian” congregation still gathered for worship. Forced to flee Russia after the Bolsheviks rose to power, they were adherents of Patriarch Tikhon (born Vasily Ivanovich Belavin) whose restoration of the Moscow Patriarchate was meant to return Russian Orthodoxy to a condition unmarred by State interference. That Russian Orthodox community’s witness of faith and fidelity was profoundly moving. Consequently, the Russian Orthodox Church I confronted outside of that chapel, infected by Sergianism, left me wondering why and how it all went wrong.
In your book Wolves in Sheep’s Clothing: The Russian Orthodox Church’s Threat to European Security and Democracy, co-authored with Oksana Shadrina, you argue that the Moscow Patriarchate has become an instrument of the Kremlin’s political influence and poses a threat to European security.
Our research included an exhaustive survey of the literature with 452 bibliographical references covering nine languages. We did not simply start with a thesis and engage in negative hypothesis building. We followed the research and evidence to where it led us. Sadly, our fears were confirmed.
Be it bending Christ’s condemnation of war into a formal sanctification by an un-Orthodox Holy War theology, the punishment of clergy and laity for rejecting Russia’s invasions in Moldova, Georgia, Ukraine, or its blessing of the Wagner-led mercenary activities and violence across Africa, the debasement of Russian Orthodoxy at Putin’s altar became abundantly clear. After cataloguing the scores of Moscow Patriarchate clergy exposed for engaging in espionage and expelled from countries across Europe and North America as persona non grata, it was no longer possible to come to any reasonable, alternative explanation but that the Moscow Patriarchate had debased itself by becoming part of the Russian State propaganda and intelligence apparatus. Our research also revealed the widespread practice of Russian clergy sewing discontent in Europe for the purpose of disturbing our social cohesion while simultaneously undermining democratic institutions and interfering in free and fair elections.
The activities undertaken by the Russian Orthodox Church, their focus, prevalence, and their ever-widening scope can no longer be considered accidental to the exercise of faith. We are daily witness to the systematic approach of the Moscow Patriarchate in confronting the world outside of the Russkiy Mirfor State purposes.
What research materials formed the basis of your book? Which documents, testimonies, archival sources and specific cases did you examine? What was the most surprising discovery you made during your research, and which of your conclusions do you consider most significant?
If there was only one, and there where many revelations arising from our research, it was that Putin and Patriarch Kirill rely on attempts to re-invent the historical record to justify imperial conquest. It is not the produce of national pride. The record of obscuring the extent to which Russia, aided by the Russian Orthodox Church, engaged not only in imperial conquests and reducing neighbours to suzerainties, but assiduously pursuing cultural, linguistic, artistic and national identity extermination of their neighbours to transform them into Malorussians (little Russians) was startling. To claim Ukrainians, Latvians, Estonians or as the claim as their offspring “All Slavic nations”, Russia needed to deprive them of an independent identity. The Moscow Patriarchate has always been the enabler of this practice.
Consider Ukraine. Autocephaly would have kept them in Moscow’s orbit. This was not good enough. Moscow witnessed a free, economically successful country on their border feverishly recovering their national identity after several centuries of Russian oppression. Casting aside folklore and Moscow Patriarchate dogma, Ukrainians began to think for themselves and rediscover their religious history had always been rooted in Constantinople. That was intolerable. Russian sought to use political power, financial interest, the bully pulpit and threat of excommunication in an attempt to maintain the myth Ukrainians were not little Russians, they had their own language, their own history, culture and tradition of worship and faith tied to Constantinople. When this failed, invasion and occupation became their only option. Now, Russia’s latest terms for peace demands Europe returns to the Warsaw Pact borders of the Cold War. They fear successful countries on their border and know that a people free of coercion and fear would never voluntarily opt to live under the Russkiy Mir.
Returning to the importance of history―delving into the competing narratives in Russia’s own history as it evolved from a Mongol feudal monarchy to tsarist dictatorship and now autocracy was instructive. It exposed their own history was merely transactional political propaganda for its age. Russian has never embraced a reliable historical record―totalitarian regimes never do.
This brings us to modernity where both Putin and Patriarch Kirill constantly espouse false historical narratives as a means of territorial and religious jurisdictional apologetics. Consequently, Oksana and came to the unavoidable conclusion that the threads of history that hold Russia together today are like the yarn of a sweater―if you pull one a loose end the whole garment comes undone. As researchers, we had to unravel the garment to lay bare the truth.
How have Moscow and the leadership of the Moscow Patriarchate responded to your research and public commentary? Have there been attempts to discredit you, exert pressure on you or challenge your findings? How freely can researchers investigating the links between Russian religious institutions, the state apparatus and intelligence services operate today?
Like anyone else critical of Russia, we have suffered harassment be it from Russian diplomats or simple activists. It goes with the territory. We keep our computers secure and remain conscious of our environment for our safety. We ignore the online abuse and threats and refer them to security services when necessary. I’m aware Russian diplomats have complained to bishops and tried to stop publications or have them withdrawn. One interview I gave recently resulted in pressure on the publication to retract it and when the editorial staff asked them to identify any inaccuracies in the article they simply hung up the phone.
I speak with other researchers and writers and know they too are subjected to pressure and sometimes violence. One described how her department head was adamant she pursues other topics and cease her research and publications about Russia because donations to the university were threatened. Even within my own Church I am often pressured to remain silent or not write on certain matters.
Even within the Church there are those who nourish a perverse view that criticising Russia is tantamount to criticising Orthodoxy. Still others speak fondly about the very Russian clergy who proclaim schism, excusing them out of a misplaced sense of fond memories of yesteryear, describing them as being “personally pious” even when the preach Holy War heresy. Then there are those within the Church who profit by doing business with Russia and get a pass because they are generous donors. There is a cost to confronting those facilitate or remain silent in the midst of Russia’s multitudinous acts of assassinating its dissidents. What are we to make of the lack of outcry after seeing the resurrection of the gulag system for those who decry the destruction of democracy? And what of the silence following the deposition of Russian clergy who preach peace and refuse the prayer of the Holy Rus’? When the Church and political leaders remain shtum when Russians continue to fall out of windows to their death after falling out of favour with the Kremlin there is a problem. Christ would not remain silent. We should not.
As for threats? Most of us have ongoing contacts with security services who keep us informed about specific threats and chatter, as necessary. Fundamentally, while putting pen to paper pales in comparison to the physical courage and fortitude shown by people who have suffered armed invasion and occupation and are on the contact line defending Europe and their homeland, speaking truth to power is necessary. My pen is my only tool.
Anna Jansone
